SN equivalent to EDM's PMUP & Aussie?

[WhatsThatSmell]

I just found out last night that PMUP is discontinued.

I'm wondering how it compares to Benefit's Powderflage, but I think THAT has been discontinued, too, but I saw there were some (supposed) dupes for the Powderflage.

I'm super bummed. I only have my itty bitty containers. I know they'll last a while, but they won't last forever.

[WhatsThatSmell]

I second the motion!LOL! My mom just ran out of PMUP and asked me to order her some more and I think it's been discontinued. I'll definitely order a sample of the Date Bait for her when the Valentine's collection comes out but I would definitely love a dupe of it:)

If they are still selling it over there, I surely can't find it on the sight.

I hereby formally request a dupe.



Oxana - do you happen to know the ratio of Sunlight to Pearl Beige (or remember, after so long)?

I'm going to try Flattery, and Sleep in a Jar Extra Light Peach. Hopefully one of those will suffice, but I sure do wish they would dupe the EDM stuff. I can't believe EDM stopped making them.

[Xarata]

I think Karen doesn't dupe EDM because it's an indie company (or was, i suppose one could argue it stopped being "indie" quite some time ago...) and it's kind of in bad taste to dupe another indie company. It's one thing to take an expensive mainstream product and make a non-chemical version of it. It's another to make the exact same product and just undercut the people who created it/made it popular (even if their customer service isn't nearly as great as Karen's)


Have any of you tried something like cherry blossom shadow in place of pick me up pink?

[WhatsThatSmell]

I think Karen doesn't dupe EDM because it's an indie company (or was, i suppose one could argue it stopped being "indie" quite some time ago...) and it's kind of in bad taste to dupe another indie company. It's one thing to take an expensive mainstream product and make a non-chemical version of it. It's another to make the exact same product and just undercut the people who created it/made it popular (even if their customer service isn't nearly as great as Karen's)


Have any of you tried something like cherry blossom shadow in place of pick me up pink?

That would be somewhat true, if EDM still made the products. But then there is the whole customer service nightmare that made some of us swear off ever buying from EDM again.

I was wondering about a shadow - thanks for the input - going to check it out now...