I'd love a return of the Tobacco Vanilla scent. The smoky vanilla combination was absolutely perfect IMO, and doubly nice because they guys could wear it too. Though, personally in my house I wear it! Reminds me of a mens cologne I tested once and wish I bought the bottle of... My favorite vanilla scent was discontinued years ago

It had notes of vanilla bean, sweet praline, cream, and a touch of sexy smokiness. It was DIVINE. I miss it, it's the only scent DH has ever bought me...just a whiff of it reminds me of when we first met.
Other scents---Blackberry Vanilla... Something with figs, or cinnamon, nutmeg, or even mulberry would be nice. A crisp, clean scent sounds good. Like Cucumber and Green Tea? Those scents are so hard to make without them becoming too perfumey. I'm hyper sensitive to scents too, I can't imagine working in a place with multiple ones stocked! I can't even walk through B&BW without getting a headache. But really, my heart is with vanilla all the way!