Help me decide on a lippie...

[royalgoddessbeth]

I have the following: Eternal, Bobbi, and Fashionista. I like all of them. What do I get when I want something that's not as brown as Eternal, not as light/sheer as Bobbi, and not as bright as Fashionista?

[lwoodall10]

Polished Pink would be pretty.

[royalgoddessbeth]

Bobbi is the right tone, but I think it's just a little light. Anything along those lines? I already have Black Dahlia, but the black oxide isn't really for spring! What about Figment?

[Cupcake]

If Bobbi is the right tone, you'd probably enjoy Figment. Although it's entirely different, from your description, Aria (black label) also jumped to mind.

[egerandi]

Figment is a bit bright I think, shiny, at least. But if Black Dahlia works, then Figment would be almost the same without the black part.
Have you considered Fig Leaf? It's a matte darker plum, not brown at all (or maybe just a smidgen).

Breathless could be nice, although it's not very plummy, more like brown pink. Whirlwind is shimmery too, but in the similar color range.

[royalgoddessbeth]

I have tried Fig Leaf, which I promptly handed off to my daughter. I have Aria already, which I like. I've also tried Breathless, which I gave to my cooler-toned mother. I really love Bobbi, but I think it could be just a smidge darker. But I suppose I shall have to live with that! Plus, I know we have new lippies coming. I can wait....

[lwoodall10]

What about Whirlwind?

[lilychemgirl]

I immediately thoughjt black dahlia, then whirlwind. Also, swank over bobbi darkens it just a little and gives a more sophisticated look.