berry nice vs seedy

[sanctuary]

This shade is my favorite but I really can't tell the difference between these two. The swatch from the website is pretty similar. Anyone has got the experience of buying these two? Swatches will be really appreciated. Thanks.

[Oxana124]

Berry Nice has a little more red to it, I prefer Seedy personally. They do look different on me.
Sorry I no longer own Berry Nice to do swatches.

[sanctuary]

Thanks Oxana, at least I can now figure out how they differ

[JenW]

I can say they are very close. At one point, we even cut Seedy from the lineup. Seedy leans just a tad more blue while Berry Nice leans a tad more red. For the cool toned gals, Seedy really is spectacular. Berry Nice is more universal.

[kchalbi]

I've owned them both, I don't find them that similar on me either. I gave Berry Nice to my sister, it really didn't suit me-maybe too pinkish/red? Seedy is more plummy and more sheer-one of my favorites, works for warm-toned girls too!

[Oxana124]

I've owned them both, I don't find them that similar on me either. I gave Berry Nice to my sister, it really didn't suit me-maybe too pinkish/red? Seedy is more plummy and more sheer-one of my favorites, works for warm-toned girls too!

I am warm toned too, I've got yellow undertones. Seedy is a nice plummy shade for me. I do have a hard time pulling off reds though, so that is why Berry Nice didn't work out, too red.

[sanctuary]

Thank you so much ladies. Ok, it's clear now, I'll pick seedy

[Yisha]

I am warm toned too, I've got yellow undertones. Seedy is a nice plummy shade for me. I do have a hard time pulling off reds though, so that is why Berry Nice didn't work out, too red.

I agree with kchalbi and Oxana, I'm pale warm toned too and redish/warm lippies just don't look good on me, while plummy ones (like Seedy) are very flattering. I was wondering wether to buy Seedy or Berry Nice, then I chose Seedy because it was more blue, it was a good choice !