Silk Naturals

I am planning on placing a small order tonight and am having a hard time picking between Innocent and St. Tropez (all of the wands are calling my name). Does anyone have them to compare? Also, so ST. Tropez really look like Breathless?

Thanks

Hi Jen,

I know you like nudes so I think you would probably prefer St. Tropez. I think it's slightly different from Breathless because Breathless was too brown for me but St. Tropez is a "just right" very flattering nude pink. I put in an order for Innocent just now if you wanna wait a few days.

feyith wrote:Hi Jen,

I know you like nudes so I think you would probably prefer St. Tropez. I think it's slightly different from Breathless because Breathless was too brown for me but St. Tropez is a "just right" very flattering nude pink. I put in an order for Innocent just now if you wanna wait a few days.

I was worried about it being too brown. I know I will endup ordering all the colors if I like the formula. I act like it's life or death...MUST HAVE!!

Hopefully I'll have them tomorrow to compare! My order shipped Friday, so it should be here tomorrow or Tuesday.

But I do have St. Tropez right now and I do like it! It's pink, but a flattering pink muted pink. It would have to be more muted to be a true nude on my lips though. Does Centerfold look pink on your lips at all? St. Tropez is definitely more pink than Centerfold is, I really don't see brown in it.

I haven't tried Breathless so I can't compare them. Based on swatches alone I'd say go for St. Tropez if you prefer more nude pinks and Innocent if you're feeling adventurous pink wise!

I can't wear breathless, but I love St Tropez. Everyone seems to love St Tropez, so I would definitely recommend it. From the reviews, you can't go wrong with St. Tropez, so might as well start with that!

I think you will like St. Tropez the best. I don't have Innocent, but I have read that it is sort of a barbie pink and from your posts that doesn't really work for you. I love, love, love St. Tropez

lilychemgirl wrote:I can't wear breathless, but I love St Tropez. Everyone seems to love St Tropez, so I would definitely recommend it. From the reviews, you can't go wrong with St. Tropez, so might as well start with that!

Same here, Breathless was too brown and oddly muted on me, but I love St. Tropez. I say, go for it

JenK wrote:I am planning on placing a small order tonight and am having a hard time picking between Innocent and St. Tropez (all of the wands are calling my name). Does anyone have them to compare? Also, so ST. Tropez really look like Breathless?

Thanks

Jen,
I just got my Innocent yesterday and I think you would really like it. It is a baby pink, what I was hoping bloom would be on me. I have trouble with pinks sometimes but this one is really beautiful. It stays a light pink color, girly but not that cheapy pink if you know what I mean! It is glossy but not too much. I really love it!!

Trainer wrote:

JenK wrote:I am planning on placing a small order tonight and am having a hard time picking between Innocent and St. Tropez (all of the wands are calling my name). Does anyone have them to compare? Also, so ST. Tropez really look like Breathless?

Thanks

Jen,
I just got my Innocent yesterday and I think you would really like it. It is a baby pink, what I was hoping bloom would be on me. I have trouble with pinks sometimes but this one is really beautiful. It stays a light pink color, girly but not that cheapy pink if you know what I mean! It is glossy but not too much. I really love it!!

That's exciting! Thanks for the description. I am adding Innocent to my wishlist too

Mmm ... I'm glad I decided to order it even though it's a liquid gloss!

Can't wait to try it ... *impatient*