A bunch of lip balms. I go through about one a month or even a little faster this time of year — New England winter.

I like the Bad Girl and the Vanilla. My current tube is the White Chocolate Macadamia Nut that smells exactly like the maple walnut cupcakes my grandmother used to make when I was a kid. Nom.
For lippies: Gold Blush, Peace, Raindrops on Roses, and Modern Poet. Plus a tube of Sweet Nothing that arrived last month smelling pretty icky and got tossed immediately. And I'm really close on a handful of others that have officially reached a Lippie Nubbin State. I've already deemed 2012 the year of Finishing the Lippie and working my way through my stash. No reordering favorites until I've made a good dent.
And one jar of Perfecting Powder. Currently on my second jar and trying out the vegan formula this time.
I wear eyeshadow so seldom now that I presume I'll just be buried with my collection since I've never managed to make any headway into it whatsoever. Sigh.